Furious at the The Order for their attempted murder on them, Chris and Alex managed to kidnap their former friend Jesse and take him to an unknown wooded area in their town to question him on how they can stop The Order from targeting them. Chris and Alex brought a camera and tripod to film the event, intending to have Jesse deliver the tape to The Order as a warning message.
It is unknown how Chris and Alex kidnapped Jesse, but during the capture Chris found a tape that belonged to Greg in Jesse's room.
Jesse awoke in the woods tied to a chair. As Alex kept watch close by, Chris questioned Jesse on how he and Alex can stop The Order from targeting them, recalling how he was stabbed by the cultists earlier that year. He also furiously blamed Jesse for Greg's death, pointing out how he found Greg's tape in his room. Jesse remained quiet and stone-faced for most of the interrogation. This, along with Jesse's consistant struggling, gradually enraged Chris, who at one point beat Jesse to the ground, kicked him, and spat on him. Jesse was knocked unconscious by this attack and his arm came loose from the chair. After using duct tape to tie Jesse back to the chair, the former awakened again.
Jesse still refused to speak, which prompted Chris to douse him in gasoline and threaten to immolate him. Jesse tried to call his bluff, but Chris lit a match and advanced toward Jesse, causing him to panic and give in. Jesse reveals that The Order's Oracle prophecized that Chris and Alex will bring harm to their goal of reaching the Fourth World, and that the cult will stop at nothing until they are dead. Chris and Alex were forced to let Jesse go when people arrived on the site.